|
|
||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||
|
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Expectations | |||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||
Students should enter grades 912 with a good understanding of measurement concepts and well-developed measurement skills. In addition to reading measurements directly from instruments, students should have calculated distances indirectly and used derived measures, such as rates.
Opportunities to use and understand measurement arise naturally during high school
in other areas of mathematics, in science, and in technical education.
Measuring the number of revolutions per minute of an engine, vast distances
in astronomy, or microscopic molecular distances extends students' facility
with derived measures and indirect measurement. Calculator- and computer-based
measurement instruments facilitate the collection, storage, and analysis
of real-time measurement data. Through logarithmic scaling, students can
graphically represent a relatively large range of measurements. Insight
into formulas for the volume or surface area of a cone or a sphere can
be gained by applying methods of successive approximation. These aspects
of measurement, along with considerations of precision and error, are
important in the students' high school experience.
Students should enter high school adept at using rates to express measurements of some attributes. Cars and buses travel at velocities expressed in miles per hour or kilometers per hour, the growth of plants is recorded in centimeters per day, and birth rates are often reported in births per 1000 people. By the time students reach high school, they should be ready to make sound decisions about how quantities should be measured and represented, depending on the situation and the problem under consideration. For example, the velocity of an insect measured as 4 centimeters a second is easier to understand than a velocity of 0.00004 kilometers a second, although they are equal. Students extend their understanding of measurement in the sciences, where many measurements are indirect. For example, they can determine the height of a bridge if they know it takes three seconds for a ball dropped off the bridge to hit the water below.
With the widespread use of calculator and computer technologies for
gathering and displaying data, students should understand that selections
of scale and viewing window become important choices. For example, the
line f(x) = x appears to intersect
the two coordinate axes at an angle of 45 degrees only when the horizontal
and vertical scales are the same. Likewise, circles viewed on screens
where the horizontal and vertical scales differ look like ellipses. The
local and global behavior of a function shown in different viewing windows
can appear very different; at times, small differences in choices can
lead to significant differences in the visual messages. Teachers can help
students understand how to make strategic choices about scale and viewing
window so that they can solve the problems they are addressing most effectively.
Nonlinear scales help represent some naturally occurring phenomena. For example, human ears have the ability to differentiate among sounds of low intensity that are very close together, but they do not » distinguish as well among sounds of high intensity. Consequently, measures of sound intensity are often displayed on a logarithmic scale, tied to equally spaced decibel units as shown in the chart in figure 7.20 (units are in newtons per square meter). Students should be able to compare, for example, the loudness of a whisper (20 decibels) with that of a vacuum cleaner (80 decibels), noting that for each ten-decibel increase, the sound intensity increases by a factor of 10.
![]()
|
High school students should be able to make reasonable estimates and sensible judgments about the precision and accuracy of the values they report. Teachers can help students understand that measurements of continuous quantities are always approximations. For example, suppose a situation calls for determining the mass of a bar of gold bullion in the shape of a rectangular prism whose length, width, and height are measured as 27.9 centimeters, 10.2 centimeters, and 6.4 centimeters, respectively. Knowing that the density is 19 300 kilograms per cubic meter, students might compute the mass as follows:

The students need to understand that reporting the mass with this degree of precision would be misleading because it would suggest a degree of accuracy far greater than the actual accuracy of the measurement. Since the lengths of the edges are reported to the nearest tenth of a centimeter, the measurements are precise only to 0.05 centimeter. That is, the edges could actually have measures in the intervals 27.9 ± 0.05, 10.2 ± 0.05, and 6.4 ± 0.05. If students calculate the possible maximum and minimum mass, given these dimensions, they will see that at most one decimal place in accuracy is justified.
As suggested by the example above, units should be reported along with numerical
values in measurement computations. The following problem requires both
an understanding of derived measurements and facility in unit analysiskeeping
track of units during computations:
While driving through Canada in the late 1990s, a U.S. tourist put 60 liters of gas in his car. The gas cost Can$0.50 a liter (Can$ stands for Canadian dollars). The exchange rate at that time was Can$1.49 for each US$1.00 (United States dollar). The price for a gallon of gasoline in the » United States was US$0.99. The driver wanted to compare prices and decide whether a tank of gas was cheaper in the United States or Canada.
The cost of the gasoline in Canada follows:
![]()
Teachers can help students recognize that in order to compute the cost of the same quantity of gasoline in the United States, it is necessary to convert between both monetary systems and units of volume. Thus, in addition to knowing the exchange rate, it is necessary to know that there are approximately 3.79 liters in each gallon of gas. The cost of 60 liters of gasoline at the U.S. price can then be seen to be
![]()
so the gas is less expensive in the United States. This computation illustrates how unitanalysis can be helpful in keeping track of the conversions.
An important measurement idea, which also helps to establish the groundwork for
some fundamental ideas of calculus, is that the measurements of some quantities
can be determined by sequences of increasingly accurate approximations.
For example, suppose that students are exploring ways to find the volumes
of three-dimensional solids. Students should know that the volume of any
right cylinder is the product of its height and the area of its base.
Thus the volume of a right circular cylinder would be
r2h,
where r is the radius of its base and h is its
height. But how could students determine the volume of a cone?
To illustrate, the right circular cone shown in figure 7.21 has base radius 5
centimeters and height 10 centimeters. Using similar triangles, students
should be able to see that slicing the cone parallel to the base at 2-centimeter
intervals yields four nearly cylindrical disks and a small cone, each
of height 2 centimeters. Each of those five figures would fit completely
inside a cylinder that is 2 centimeters high and that has the same radius
as its bottom cross section. Hence, the cumulative volume is less than
2(![]()
52
+ ![]()
42
+ ![]()
32
+ ![]()
22
+ ![]()
12)
cm3 = 110
cm3.
At the same time, each of the five figures contains as a subset a cylinder
that has the radius of its top cross section. Thus the cumulative volume
must be at least 2(![]()
42
+ ![]()
32
+ ![]()
22
+ ![]()
12
+ ![]()
02)
cm3 = 60
cm3.
Repeating the process with 1-centimeter-thick slices would help students
see that as they take thinner slices of the cone, the overestimates and
underestimates of the volume get increasingly close to each other. (Indeed,
the averages of the underestimates and overestimates rapidly approach
the actual volume of (83 1/3)
cm3.)
Informally, such experiences serve as an introduction to the idea of approximation
by using upper and lower bounds and to the idea of limits. Whether or
not these ideas are pursued later in formal coursework, they can introduce
powerful ways of thinking about mathematical phenomena and help students
establish a basic familiarity with core ideas of calculus.
![]()
|
| NCTM Home | Illuminations Web site |
|
|