Home      To Homepage To NCTM Website PreK-2   3 - 5   6 - 8   9 - 12  Across
Site Map  i-Math Reflections Resources Lesson Plans Standards
To E-Standards To Marco Polo
Lesson Plan


Whelk-Come to Mathematics: Using Rational Functions to Investigate the Behavior of Northwestern Crows
Part Two - Conduct an Experiment

 
Make a Conjecture
Conduct an Experiment
Analyze the Data
Work to a Conclusion

Are the crows minimizing their work by dropping whelk as they dos? The amount of work depends upon the height of the drop and the number of times the crow has to fly to this height. To answer the question, the relationship between the height of the drop and the number of drops is needed.

Reto Zach * conducted the following experiment. He repeatedly dropped a whelk from a fixed height until the whelk broke. He recorded the height and the number of drops required. He repeated this for several different heights. The dropping of whelk can be simulated by dropping peanuts or other objects. Peanuts are a good choice because they are relatively inexpensive and fairly uniform.

If you do not wish to conduct an experiment to gather your own data, then use the sample data provided.

The Experiment: To model the dropping of whelks, get a meterstick and a cup of whole, blanched peanuts that have been removed from their shells. Start with a height of 15 cm. Repeatedly drop a peanut until it breaks into two pieces. Record the number of drops needed for the peanut to break. Repeat this experiment for at least eight peanuts at this same height. Find the mean number of drops required to break open a peanut. Repeat this experiment for heights of 20, 25, 30, 35, 40, 50 and 60 centimeters. You may want to pool your data with data obtained by other groups in the class. Record the data in a table similar to the following.

Use Sample Data

Reset Data

Show Graph

 

Height of Drop

N
U
M
B
E
R
 
O
F
 
D
R
O
P
S
 
Peanut
Number 
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

Avg.

Std. Dev.

 

 

Reflect on the Experiment

Examine the patterns in the data that you have produced. Compare your findings to the conjectures that you made previously.
  1. Are your conjectures confirmed or disputed? What changes in your conjectures would you make?
     
  2. At which height should more peanuts be dropped to get more accurate data? Why?
    • How is this fact evident in your data?
    • How can you decide when enough peanuts at a given height have been dropped?
       
  3. Do you think there are a minimum number of drops required to break open a peanut?
     
  4. Do you think there is a minimum height required to break open a peanut?
     
  5. What type of function do you think could be used to model the data that you've collected?


Make a Conjecture
Conduct an Experiment
Analyze the Data
Work to a Conclusion


Credits and References



 homesearchcontactNCTM


© 2000 - National Council of Teachers of Mathematics

This page URL:
CD Version last updated: September 21, 2000